Labour-only driver companies face tax and licence risks
Yesterday’s SCS Haulage notice records a formal warning and binding driver-engagement promises, while payroll rules already expose agencies and clients to recovery.
The Eastern Traffic Commissioner’s notice published yesterday, 14 October 2026, records a formal warning against SCS Haulage Ltd and says its repute has been tarnished. It also records an undertaking [a binding promise to the regulator] that permanent drivers will be employed through PAYE [the system for deducting employment tax], with temporary drivers employed through an agency without personal service companies [companies through which individuals supply their work].
What this means if you are a director: if your company exists only to invoice for your labour, while the engager supplies the vehicle and everything else, you are exposed. HMRC’s Employment Status Manual says commercial drivers supplying only labour, using vehicles owned, maintained and insured by the engager, are likely to be employees. Your company invoice does not settle your status.
You may be angry that an arrangement you have used for years is being challenged. That does not make it safe. The Traffic Commissioners’ account of Enero Logistics warns that HMRC can pursue workers, agents and operators where legal requirements are breached. The driver, the company and the agency can all be sanctioned under the rules applying to them. Liability does not automatically stop with whoever issued the invoice.
Regulators are stepping up the obligations on labour supply chains. HMRC’s umbrella-company guidance says rules covering payments from 6 April 2026 make the agency contracting with the end client—or the client where there is no agency—responsible for ensuring PAYE is operated correctly when an umbrella employs workers. HMRC can recover underpayments from that agency or client. Passing payroll down the chain no longer means leaving the recovery risk there.
SCS’s undertaking applies to its licence. It is not a universal ban on agencies or personal service companies. But the notice expressly warns that repetition can bring more serious intervention. It records a licensing sanction, not an assessed HMRC IR35 bill [a tax assessment under rules covering work supplied through an intermediary].
Enero shows why replacing a driver’s company with an agency is not enough. Traffic Commissioner Richard Turfitt’s decision records an earlier undertaking to employ permanent drivers, followed by an arrangement with WOM Recruitment Ltd. Financial evidence showed substantial agency payments without obvious wages. Turfitt rejected director Leszek Robert Lembicz’s explanation that he was confused about the undertaking.
Turfitt reduced Enero’s vehicle authority to five, according to his decision, and severely tarnished the operator’s repute and the director’s fitness. The business retained permission to operate, but with reduced capacity. The immediate commercial cost fell on the operator; the decision does not quantify payroll savings or assess a tax debt against every participant.
Point 2 Point Transport 85 Ltd lost its licence. Deputy Traffic Commissioner Gerallt Evans’s decision records service-company payments and director Nedyalko Tsonchev’s belief that being below an IR35 threshold made them acceptable. Revocation also involved maintenance, brake testing and an invalid transport-manager qualification. Neither the operator nor Tsonchev was disqualified from holding an operator’s licence. This was not an IR35-only revocation.
Small-client status is not a certificate of self-employment. HMRC’s supply-chain guidance distinguishes the reformed off-payroll rules, applying to public-sector and medium or large private-sector clients, from other employment-status and agency questions. The umbrella rules also have exceptions, including qualifying personal-service-company arrangements. An exception from one regime does not answer obligations under another.
The immediate threat is practical: work can continue only on arrangements that satisfy the applicable tax rules and licence promises. Enero demonstrates that continued operation can remain possible after intervention. Point 2 Point demonstrates that a promise to correct matters need not save a licence. Neither outcome is something you should gamble your income on.
What to do
- Read the letter and record the deadline today. Identify who sent it, whether it addresses you or the company, the conduct alleged and the periods covered. Distinguish an HMRC enquiry from a Traffic Commissioner call-up [notice requiring attendance at a public inquiry]. Make a checklist against the actual requests. Enero’s decision shows how an earlier licence undertaking can become central to later action.
- Stop using the labour-only company to invoice for further driving assignments this week. Tell the engager that the payment arrangement must change before further work proceeds. Seek direct employment or an agency employment arrangement that meets the applicable requirements. Do not assume that inserting another company fixes the problem: Enero’s agency arrangement failed to satisfy its earlier undertaking.
- Preserve the records before changing anything. Keep signed contracts, agency terms, invoices, bank statements, payslips, payroll submissions and correspondence about employment offers. Write down who supplies, maintains and insures the vehicle, who allocates work and what actually happens on each assignment. Keep earlier versions of documents. HMRC’s manual makes vehicle provision central to its published warning about labour-only drivers.
- Map the payment chain and compare it with the licence. Identify the engager, agency, employer and company issuing invoices. Read every driver-engagement undertaking, not just the commercial contract. Check which party accounts for deductions under the applicable rules. HMRC’s guidance makes clear that responsibilities depend on the engagement model and your position in the chain; a payroll arrangement does not erase a separate licence promise.
- Cost compliant work before agreeing the next rate. Request a breakdown of gross pay, deductions, employer costs and agency charges. Check payslips against payments received and retain the evidence. Where an umbrella employs you, establish who is checking its payroll compliance. HMRC says the umbrella remains responsible for payroll, while the relevant agency or client can face recovery of underpayments.
- Submit an evidenced response by the stated deadline. Explain corrections already completed and attach the records requested; do not substitute assurances for action. Check the correct licensing jurisdiction: Scotland is within the Great Britain Traffic Commissioner system, while Northern Ireland has separate operator-licensing legislation and administration.
Do not
- Do not carry on invoicing through a labour-only company because the engager or agency says everyone does it. HMRC’s published position puts that arrangement squarely at risk where the engager owns, maintains and insures the vehicle. This week, stop using that invoicing arrangement, preserve the contracts and payroll evidence, and check any response deadline. Do not wait to be caught.



